Public Health (Tobacco and Other Products) (Consequential Amendments and Transitional Provisions)

Current status

This bill became law on Dec 14th, 2023.

Policy area

Health, care & disability

What does this bill do?

Australia replaces the old federal tobacco advertising and plain packagingThe rule that tobacco packs must look plain and not use branding to make products seem attractive. The page treats it as one of the older laws being folded into the new regime. laws with the new single tobacco law by repealing the Tobacco Advertising Prohibition Act 1992The old federal law that banned tobacco advertising. This bill removes or updates parts of it so the new tobacco rules can work as one system..

Why was it introduced?

Australia’s tobacco laws were split across multiple old acts and had gaps for e-cigarette advertising, new products, and the shift to a new single tobacco regime. This bill repeals and updates old laws, aligns e-cigarette ad rules, and sets transition periods and reporting rules so the new system can start smoothly.

Broader context

Australia already had strong tobacco controls such as plain packagingThe rule that tobacco packs must look plain and not use branding to make products seem attractive. The page treats it as one of the older laws being folded into the new regime., but by 2023 the federal rules were spread across eight laws and did not neatly cover newer products and e-cigarette advertising, while smoking still remained a leading cause of preventable death and disability. The government responded by introducing a companion bill to fold old tobacco statutes into one new regime, align broadcasting and datacastingA broadcasting-like service covered by media advertising rules. The page says e-cigarette ads are now treated the same as tobacco ads in these rules. advertising rules, and manage a staged changeover, with Parliament passing it in December 2023 and Royal AssentThe formal step that turns a passed bill into an Act. The page says this happened soon after Parliament passed the bill. following soon after.

Key criticism

The main criticism was that the bill tidied up the legal transition but did not do enough to stop illegal tobacco, black-market sales and vaping loopholes, so critics warned the problem would simply shift rather than be solved. That concern came mainly from Coalition and Nationals speakers, with some crossbench supporters also saying the bill needed stronger enforcement and wider vaping controls even while backing its overall direction.

Who supported it?

Hon Mark Butler MP introduced this bill. It passed on the voices.

Introduced in House 13 Sept 2023
Passed House 19 Oct 2023
Passed Senate 05 Dec 2023
Became law 14 Dec 2023

Did it become law?

Yes

Became law 14 Dec 2023

Final passage

Passed without a counted vote

3 recorded amendment or procedural votes were found, but no counted vote on the bill itself was recorded.

Passage speed

92 days

From introduction to the latest recorded parliamentary step

Official record

View on APH

Parliament of Australia bill page

What does this bill do?

  1. Australia replaces the old federal tobacco advertising and plain packagingThe rule that tobacco packs must look plain and not use branding to make products seem attractive. The page treats it as one of the older laws being folded into the new regime. laws with the new single tobacco law by repealing the Tobacco Advertising Prohibition Act 1992The old federal law that banned tobacco advertising. This bill removes or updates parts of it so the new tobacco rules can work as one system..

  2. Broadcasting and datacastingA broadcasting-like service covered by media advertising rules. The page says e-cigarette ads are now treated the same as tobacco ads in these rules. rules now treat e-cigarette ads the same as tobacco ads under the new federal tobacco law.

  3. Tobacco companies get 12 months to shift to the new packaging and product rules, and retailers get another 3 months to sell old stock already supplied to them.

  4. Tobacco businesses must start giving yearly reports on ingredients, sales volumes and promotional spending from the 2024-2025 financial year onward.

  5. The Health Minister can make extra transition rules to help the changeover, but cannot use those rules to create offences, impose taxes or directly rewrite the law.

Show source excerpts
  1. Repeal the Act.
    Public Health (Tobacco and Other Products) (Consequential Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Act 2023 final Act text
  2. Omit “Tobacco Advertising Prohibition Act 1992, broadcast a tobacco advertisement”, substitute “Public Health (Tobacco and Other Products) Act 2023, broadcast a tobacco advertisement or an e‑cigarette advertisement”.
    Public Health (Tobacco and Other Products) (Consequential Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Act 2023 final Act text
  3. main transition period means the period of 12 months beginning on the commencement day.
    Public Health (Tobacco and Other Products) (Consequential Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Act 2023 final Act text
  4. (a) the 2024‑2025 financial year; and
    Public Health (Tobacco and Other Products) (Consequential Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Act 2023 final Act text
  5. (1) The Minister may, by legislative instrument, make rules prescribing matters:
    Public Health (Tobacco and Other Products) (Consequential Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Act 2023 final Act text

Broader context for this bill

Australia already had strong tobacco controls such as plain packagingThe rule that tobacco packs must look plain and not use branding to make products seem attractive. The page treats it as one of the older laws being folded into the new regime., but by 2023 the federal rules were spread across eight laws and did not neatly cover newer products and e-cigarette advertising, while smoking still remained a leading cause of preventable death and disability. The government responded by introducing a companion bill to fold old tobacco statutes into one new regime, align broadcasting and datacastingA broadcasting-like service covered by media advertising rules. The page says e-cigarette ads are now treated the same as tobacco ads in these rules. advertising rules, and manage a staged changeover, with Parliament passing it in December 2023 and Royal AssentThe formal step that turns a passed bill into an Act. The page says this happened soon after Parliament passed the bill. following soon after.

  1. 13 Sept 2023

    Government says tobacco laws are scattered across eight federal regimes

    The explanatory material said Commonwealth tobacco regulation had become spread across eight Acts, instruments and court decisions, creating a case for one modern law.

    Australian Parliament House ↗
  2. 13 Sept 2023

    Government introduces the consequential bill for the new tobacco regime

    The minister introduced the bill as the companion measure needed to update old legal references and make the consolidated tobacco law work in practice.

    Hansard ↗
  3. 18 Oct 2023

    Parliament debates modernising rules for smoking and e-cigarettes

    Speakers said smoking still causes major illness and death while the law needed to catch up with modern tobacco products and e-cigarette advertising.

    Hansard ↗
  4. 19 Oct 2023

    House passes the bill

    The bill cleared the House, sending the transition and consequential changes to the Senate alongside the main tobacco reform package.

    Parliamentary timeline ↗
  5. 05 Dec 2023

    Parliament passes the bill

    Both houses agreed to the bill in the same form, completing the legislative package needed to shift from older tobacco laws to the single new scheme.

    Parliamentary timeline ↗
  6. 14 Dec 2023

    Royal AssentThe formal step that turns a passed bill into an Act. The page says this happened soon after Parliament passed the bill. makes the transition law official

    Royal AssentThe formal step that turns a passed bill into an Act. The page says this happened soon after Parliament passed the bill. turned the bill into an Act so the repeal, advertising alignment, reporting rules and phased sell-through arrangements could take effect under the new framework.

    Parliamentary timeline ↗

How did it move through Parliament?

House Senate
Introduced 13 Sept 2023

The bill was formally presented to the chamber and read a first time, which starts its parliamentary journey.

Introduced and read a first time

Second reading opened 13 Sept 2023

A minister or sponsoring member moved the second reading, opening the main debate on the bill's purpose and principles.

Second reading moved

Community Affairs review 14 Sept 2023

Referred to Committee (14/09/2023): Senate Community Affairs Legislation Committee; Committee report (22/11/2023)

Referred to committee

APH bill page notes
Second reading debate 17 Oct 2023

The bill reached this recorded parliamentary step.

Sent to Federation Chamber for debate 17 Oct 2023

The bill reached this recorded parliamentary step.

Referred to Federation Chamber

Second reading debate 18 Oct 2023

The bill reached this recorded parliamentary step.

House second reading agreed 18 Oct 2023

The chamber agreed to the bill at second reading, meaning it accepted the bill in principle and allowed it to continue.

Second reading agreed to

Returned from Federation Chamber 19 Oct 2023

The bill reached this recorded parliamentary step.

Reported from Federation Chamber

House third reading agreed 19 Oct 2023

The chamber agreed to the bill at third reading, which completed passage through that chamber.

Third reading agreed to

Introduced 19 Oct 2023

The bill was formally presented to the chamber and read a first time, which starts its parliamentary journey.

Introduced and read a first time

Second reading opened 19 Oct 2023

A minister or sponsoring member moved the second reading, opening the main debate on the bill's purpose and principles.

Second reading moved

Second reading debate 27 Nov 2023

The bill reached this recorded parliamentary step.

Second reading debate 04 Dec 2023

The bill reached this recorded parliamentary step.

Senate second reading agreed 04 Dec 2023

The chamber agreed to the bill at second reading, meaning it accepted the bill in principle and allowed it to continue.

Second reading agreed to

Committee of the Whole debate 04 Dec 2023

The bill reached this recorded parliamentary step.

Senate third reading agreed 05 Dec 2023

The chamber agreed to the bill at third reading, which completed passage through that chamber.

Third reading agreed to

Passed both houses 05 Dec 2023

Both houses passed the bill in the same form, completing parliamentary passage.

Finally passed both Houses

Assent 14 Dec 2023

The Governor-General gave Royal AssentThe formal step that turns a passed bill into an Act. The page says this happened soon after Parliament passed the bill., turning the bill into an Act.

The main case against this bill

The main criticism was that the bill tidied up the legal transition but did not do enough to stop illegal tobacco, black-market sales and vaping loopholes, so critics warned the problem would simply shift rather than be solved. That concern came mainly from Coalition and Nationals speakers, with some crossbench supporters also saying the bill needed stronger enforcement and wider vaping controls even while backing its overall direction.

Criticism was real but mostly conditional, not broad opposition to the bill’s public health goal.

Does not tackle illegal tobacco strongly enough

Critics argued the bill focuses on transitional legal changes and advertising rules without matching action against illegal tobacco and black-market sales. They warned that tighter rules on paper could be undermined if enforcement and penalties do not keep pace with the illicit trade.

Raised by Coalition and Nationals speakers, including Sussan Ley, Anne Webster and Aaron Violi Source ↗

Too limited on vaping loopholes and practical safeguards

Some supporters said the bill was welcome but incomplete because it did not fully close loopholes around vape advertising, online sales and related influence, and would only matter if enforcement was strong. The criticism was less about the bill’s health objective than about whether its drafting and follow-through were wide enough to change behaviour in practice.

Raised by Crossbench supporters including Zali Steggall and Allegra Spender Source ↗

Recorded votes

How the bill itself passed

The bill passed both chambers on the voices. The counted divisions below were about amendments or procedure, not final passage.

Passed

House passed the bill

House agreed to the bill's third reading on the voices, so there is no list of individual Aye and No votes for final passage in that chamber.

19 Oct 2023

Passed on the voices

In a voice vote, members call out Aye or No and the presiding officer judges which side has it. Individual names are only recorded if a formal division is called.

Passed

Senate passed the bill

Senate agreed to the bill's third reading on the voices, so there is no list of individual Aye and No votes for final passage in that chamber.

05 Dec 2023

Passed on the voices

In a voice vote, members call out Aye or No and the presiding officer judges which side has it. Individual names are only recorded if a formal division is called.

Amendments at a glance

Recorded amendment and procedural votes grouped by chamber. Expand a vote to see the party breakdown.

Senate

Defeated

Tackle illicit tobacco trade

Aye 28 No 30

Defeated 28 to 30. Support came from Liberal Party, Nationals, Jacqui Lambie Network, and One Nation. Opposition came from Labor, Greens, and minor parties and independents. Minor-party and independent votes were split.

04 Dec 2023

The Senate rejected the amendment, so the bill proceeded without that extra call for stronger action against illicit tobaccoTobacco sold outside the legal system, often as black-market product. Critics on the page say the bill does not do enough to stop it. and vaping black markets.

Party Recorded votes Aye / No
Labor 0 / 17
Liberal Party 14 / 0
Unknown 7 / 3
Greens 0 / 9
Nationals 4 / 0
Independent 0 / 1
Jacqui Lambie Network 1 / 0
One Nation 1 / 0
UAP 1 / 0
Carried

Stop tobacco industry influence

Aye 32 No 24

Passed 32 to 24. Support came from Labor, Greens, Jacqui Lambie Network, and minor parties and independents. Opposition came from Liberal Party, Nationals, and UAP. Minor-party and independent votes were split.

04 Dec 2023

The Senate agreed to the amendment, so the bill’s second-reading statement included a formal call to curb tobacco industry access and political influence.

Party Recorded votes Aye / No
Labor 17 / 0
Liberal Party 0 / 14
Greens 9 / 0
Unknown 4 / 5
Nationals 0 / 4
Independent 1 / 0
Jacqui Lambie Network 1 / 0
UAP 0 / 1
Defeated

Create regulated vaping market

Aye 3 No 38

Defeated 3 to 38. Support came from One Nation and UAP. Opposition came from Labor, Greens, Liberal Party, Jacqui Lambie Network, and minor parties and independents. Nationals had split recorded votes.

05 Dec 2023

The Senate rejected the package, so the bill did not gain Canavan’s proposed regulated vaping framework.

Party Recorded votes Aye / No
Labor 0 / 16
Greens 0 / 7
Liberal Party 0 / 6
Unknown 0 / 5
Independent 0 / 2
Nationals 1 / 1
Jacqui Lambie Network 0 / 1
One Nation 1 / 0
UAP 1 / 0

These are amendment votes, not the final passage vote on the bill itself. The bill passed both chambers on the voices.

Who spoke, and what they said

Start here — lead voices

Sponsor speech Supports

Mark Butler

Australian Labor Party • MP 13 Sept 2023

Butler supports the bill because it makes the transition to the new tobacco control regime workable and updates related laws.

Read in Hansard ↗
Lead opposing voice Opposes

Tammy Tyrrell

Jacqui Lambie Network • Senator 04 Dec 2023

Tyrrell opposes the bill because she says the government is relying on bans and tighter restrictions instead of a sensible harm-reduction approach, and argues that making legal vaping harder to access will push people back toward cigarettes and the black market.

Read in Hansard ↗
Lead supporting voice Supports

Peter Whish-Wilson

Australian Greens • Senator 04 Dec 2023

Whish-Wilson supports the bill and uses the second reading stage to push for stronger environmental rules on tobacco packaging, especially banning single-use plastic film and tear strips and requiring recycled, recyclable cardboard.

Read in Hansard ↗
Lead non-major voice Supports

David Pocock

Independent • Senator 04 Dec 2023

Pocock supports the bill and says it modernises tobacco control by preserving plain-packaging rules and tightening warnings, additives and advertising restrictions.

Read in Hansard ↗

All speeches by bloc

Labor

13 speakers · 13 support

  1. Shayne Neumann Shayne Neumann supports the bill and says it is needed to modernise and streamline Australia’s tobacco laws while adding stronger controls on vaping and other nicotine products.
    “I rise to support the Public Health (Tobacco and other Products) Bill 2023. This bill consolidates the existing Commonwealth tobacco control framework into one act with associated regulations, thereby streamlining the operation of the laws. It modernises and simplifies existing provisions and introduces some new measures to discourage smoking. It addresses the health risks posed by vaping and e-cigarette products.”

    Australian Labor Party • MP • 18 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  2. Louise Miller-Frost Miller-Frost supports the bill as part of a broader push to strengthen tobacco control and reduce smoking uptake, especially among young people.
    “The Public Health (Tobacco and Other Products) (Consequential Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2023 deals with the consequential and transitional matters arising from the enactment of the bill. Among other things, it provides application, saving and transitional provisions to allow a smooth transition to the new requirements, including a main transitional period of 12 months to allow manufacturers ample time to bring products in line with the new requirements, along with a retailer transition sell-through period of a further three months.”

    Australian Labor Party • MP • 18 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  3. Tracey Roberts Roberts supports the bill and says it is needed to modernise, simplify and consolidate tobacco control law, reduce duplication, and strengthen regulation.
    “In conclusion, I acknowledge there are many pieces of legislation governing tobacco control within Australia, which has created ambiguity regarding compliance, duplication of reporting, and enforcement. It is time to consolidate existing legislation to reduce red tape and the possible duplication of portfolio responsibility for policy and enforcement. I am supportive of the government's efforts to modernise, simplify and consolidate tobacco control.”

    Australian Labor Party • MP • 18 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  4. Graham Perrett Graham Perrett supports the bill as part of Labor's tobacco-control package, saying it streamlines the law, closes loopholes and strengthens measures to reduce smoking and vaping.
    “This bill brings together tobacco measures along with 11 new measures into a single streamlined and effective act of parliament, which will re-ignite the fight against tobacco and nicotine addiction.”

    Australian Labor Party • MP • 18 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  5. Zaneta Mascarenhas Mascarenhas supports the bill and says it is needed to strengthen tobacco control, simplify the patchwork of existing laws, and protect children and public health.
    “Really, this is about the future of our children. It's about the future of the health of our people in Australia, so I commend this bill to the House.”

    Australian Labor Party • MP • 18 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  6. Tim Ayres Ayres supports the bill because it is the machinery needed to put the main tobacco-control legislation into effect and to manage a smooth transition to the new regime.
    “In conclusion, this Bill supports the main Bill in modernising, simplifying and consolidating our efforts in tobacco control.”

    Australian Labor Party • Senator • 19 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  7. Anne Stanley Stanley supports the bill and says it will help implement the government’s tobacco reforms and strengthen Australia’s public health response.
    “The substantive ability to prescribe such requirements are included in the bill, while the requirements themselves will be contained in the regulations, which are subject to disallowance. This supports an approach that is adaptive to an evolving public health issue, contemporary political advice and changes in technology and the market more generally.”

    Australian Labor Party • MP • 18 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  8. Carina Garland Garland says Labor supports the bill and wants it passed because it modernises and strengthens tobacco controls, closes loopholes, and keeps the laws current as smoking and vaping tactics change.
    “I'm really pleased to support the Public Health (Tobacco and Other Products) Bill today. As the Minister for Health has stated, this bill builds on the pioneering tobacco control reforms introduced by past Labor governments, which include Australia's world-leading tobacco plain-packaging reforms.”

    Australian Labor Party • MP • 18 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  9. Michelle Ananda-Rajah Ananda-Rajah strongly backs the bill, saying it updates Australia’s tobacco laws to close loopholes, regulate vaping and novel products, and help meet national smoking-reduction targets.
    “The overarching objective is to reduce the prevalence of smoking by reducing uptake, with a particular focus on young people—on children. When it comes to smoking-related harm, prevention really is better than the cure. These reforms will help restore our edge in tobacco control with our children and adults—young and older, Indigenous and non-Indigenous—the beneficiaries. I commend this bill to the House.”

    Australian Labor Party • MP • 18 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  10. Marielle Smith Smith supports the bill and says it is needed to save lives by reducing smoking and updating Australia’s tobacco rules.
    “Australia has been a world leader in tobacco regulation and reform before. Under the Albanese Labor government we will be world leaders again. I commend these bills to the Senate.”

    Australian Labor Party • Senator • 04 Dec 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  11. Ged Kearney Kearney supports the bill, saying it streamlines and modernises Australia's tobacco laws while adding stronger warnings, tighter advertising restrictions and other measures to reduce smoking and vaping.
    “The main bill consolidated the existing Commonwealth tobacco control framework into one act with associated regulations, streamlining the operation of the laws. It modernises and simplifies the existing provisions and it introduces new measures to discourage smoking and prevent the promotion of vaping and e-cigarette products. The bill reflects the Australian government's ongoing commitment to improving the health of all Australians by reducing the prevalence of tobacco use, the leading cause of preventable death and disability among Australians, and its associated health, social and environmental costs and the inequality it causes.”

    Australian Labor Party • MP • 18 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  12. Malarndirri McCarthy Malarndirri McCarthy supports the bill and says it will strengthen and streamline Australia's tobacco control laws, including measures to curb smoking and the promotion of vaping and other novel products.
    “I conclude by saying that the government is determined to do all we can to tackle the harms caused by smoking. We know that the tobacco industry continues to have deep pockets and very powerful friends. This government is up for the fight, because we fight on behalf of the most vulnerable and disadvantaged in our society, who bear the brunt of these tobacco company profits. We're going to bring the same spirit of courage, the same spirit of action, the same clarity of thought and, I hope, the same conviction that Nicola Roxon brought to plain-packaging reforms 12 years ago. We're going to reaffirm Australia's reputation as a world leader in tobacco control. I commend the bill.”

    Australian Labor Party • Senator • 04 Dec 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗

Coalition

6 speakers · 3 support · 1 oppose · 2 mixed

  1. Matthew Canavan Canavan says he cannot support the bill in its current form and will move amendments to legalise and regulate vaping, because he считает the current approach ignores illicit tobaccoTobacco sold outside the legal system, often as black-market product. Critics on the page say the bill does not do enough to stop it. and simply pushes users into the black market.
    “There is another way here. We don't need to criminalise 1.3 million Australians. We don't need to help the criminal gangs with this trade. We can do what every other developed country in the world now does and create a legal, regulated e-cigarette vaping market. I will move amendments in the committee stage of this bill to do that very thing.”

    Liberal National Party • Senator • 04 Dec 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  2. Kerrynne Liddle Liddle says the coalition will support the bill because it improves tobacco warnings, reporting and restrictions, but argues it is weakened by failing to properly tackle the illegal tobacco market.
    “These are all worthy initiatives, and the coalition supports these initiatives, but we seek to strengthen the penalties for those who participate in the illegal trade in tobacco products.”

    Liberal Party • Senator • 04 Dec 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  3. Anne Webster Webster says the Nationals support the goal of improving public health, but oppose this bill because they think it is half-baked, will fuel the black market, and fails to address vaping properly.
    “Vaping is a scourge on our youth, just like cigarettes are. Australia solved the latter through regulation, a method which we can repeat when it comes to vapes. Regulation will curtail the criminally run black market trade that is so rampant when it comes to vaping. It will also ease the burden on our health system, cutting down on the need for vaping users to clog up our general practice waiting rooms. From there, we can seek to fully address other health issues. I reiterate that the intent of this bill is right, but I caution the minister about unintended consequences and call on this parliament to have a serious discussion about a better way forward.”

    National Party • MP • 18 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  4. Aaron Violi Violi says the coalition supports the bill's intent, but wants the committee inquiry's findings to be considered and argues the legislation should also do more to tackle vaping supply and the illegal tobacco trade.
    “While the coalition supports the intent of this bill, it is essential to note that the Senate committee inquiry has commenced with a reporting date of 22 November. Any significant issues that arise from this report should be taken into consideration. The bills do not address the stronger regulation of e-cigarette availability, vapes and supply. They only seek to prohibit certain forms of e-cigarette advertisements and sponsorships.”

    Liberal Party • MP • 18 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  5. Ross Cadell Cadell says the coalition will support the bill, mainly because it is better than doing nothing and makes legal products safer.
    “This legislation will be supported by us, because it's better than not supporting it, and it's better to make the legal products safer.”

    National Party • Senator • 04 Dec 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  6. Sussan Ley Ley says the coalition supports the bill in principle because it strengthens tobacco control, but she argues it is incomplete because it does not deal properly with the growing illegal tobacco trade.
    “While the coalition supports the intention of this bill, it is essential to mention that a Senate committee inquiry has commenced, with a reporting date of 22 November. Any significant issues arising from this report should be taken into consideration. We understand that there are concerns about the costs associated with these measures. However, it's important to note that the government has proposed that the costs be met through existing resources of the Department of Health and Aged Care. Other costs due to the legislated changes will be borne by the industry. I strongly note that the coalition will have more to say about this bill when it comes before the Senate. However, it is with deep disappointment that we express our concerns regarding a crucial aspect that this bill does not address: the rampant and growing issue of the illegal tobacco trade in our country.”

    Liberal Party • MP • 17 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗

Greens

2 speakers · 2 support

  1. David Shoebridge Shoebridge says the Greens support the bill, arguing it is a necessary part of regulating tobacco in the public interest and simplifying the federal framework.
    “The Greens support this legislation, which is largely about consolidating, simplifying and clarifying the way in which federal legislation regulates tobacco.”

    Australian Greens • Senator • 04 Dec 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗

Minor parties and independents

5 speakers · 3 support · 2 oppose

  1. Zali Steggall Steggall supports the bill, but says it should be strengthened to close loopholes on vape advertising, online sales and political donations from vaping companies.
    “I'm supportive of this legislation, but I will put forward amendments with the intent of making this legislation even better and make a statement on what I know are the expectations of parents around the country. We need to delete a number of clauses from this legislation. The practical effect of this will be to further restrict physical advertising, online advertising and advertising on aeroplanes for vapes and online sale of vapes. The amendment in relation to the clause on political donations and electoral expenses will ensure that our political system is not influenced by donations from the vaping lobby.”

    Independent • MP • 18 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  2. Ralph Babet Babet opposes the bill, saying it is just more nanny-state regulation and that extra warnings on individual cigarettes will not change smokers' behaviour.
    “This bill obviously goes even further: apparently a package insert and warnings on individual cigarettes. That's going to make all the difference! I'm sure that, once someone opens a packet, lights up a cigarette and puts it in their mouth, they're going to glance down and see 'smoking kills' written on that cigarette and immediately get the urge to quit smoking. That's what they're going to do—sure; no worries! I'm sorry to break it to you, guys: if a picture of mouth cancer or lung cancer on the front of a packet does not convince a smoker to quit, a little label on an individual cigarette will not convince them. The Australian people are not stupid. They can read. As adults—I'll keep saying it—they can make their own decisions.”

    United Australia Party • Senator • 04 Dec 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗
  3. Allegra Spender Spender supports the bill and says it is an overdue step to restrict tobacco and e-cigarette promotion, especially to young people.
    “Regulating the sale and advertisement of tobacco and e-cigarette products is an essential and overdue step. I commend the government for listening to the concerns of the community and introducing this legislation.”

    Independent • MP • 18 Oct 2023

    Read the full speech in Hansard ↗

Full record

Full chat